Guzman v. Hacienda Records and Recording

Docket Number: 15-40297
Judge: Carl E. Stewart
Opinion Date: December 14, 2015

This dispute involves two Tejano songs: “Triste Aventurera” and “Cartas de Amor.” Plaintiff filed suit against Hacienda alleging, inter alia, that Hacienda’s release of “Cartas” infringed upon his “Triste” copyright. The district court ruled in favor of Hacienda as to each of plaintiff’s claims. The court rejected plaintiff’s contention that the district court erred in finding no reasonable possibility of access. In this case, the court concluded that plaintiff failed to show that the district court’s access finding was clearly erroneous. The court also concluded that, absent evidence of uniqueness or complexity, and in light of the expert testimony at trial describing differences in the lyrics and music of the songs, the district court’s finding that “Cartas” and “Triste” are not strikingly similar was not clearly erroneous; the court rejected plaintiff’s invitation to apply a novel “sliding-scale” analysis that would have lowered his access burden; and plaintiff waived his Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA), 17 U.S.C. 1202(a), claim. Accordingly, the court affirmed the judgment. View “Guzman v. Hacienda Records and Recording” on Justia Law

View "Guzman v. Hacienda Records and Recording" on Justia Law

Comments are closed.