After participating in a songwriting contest co-sponsored by Sony and a well-known Puerto Rican singer, the plaintiff submitted an original song and accompanying music video for consideration. Upon advancing as a finalist, the plaintiff was asked to sign documents related to contest participation. Another entrant was ultimately selected as the contest winner. Later, the defendant released a song and video that the plaintiff claimed were substantially similar to his contest submission, leading the plaintiff to file suit for copyright infringement and allege fraudulent inducement into the contest.

Following extensive procedural history, including several prior appeals and a Supreme Court decision clarifying when copyright owners may sue, the United States District Court for the District of Puerto Rico dismissed the plaintiff’s earlier complaint without prejudice due to the timing of his copyright registration. The plaintiff then filed a new action, again asserting copyright infringement. The defendant responded with counterclaims challenging the validity of the plaintiff’s copyright registration and moved for summary judgment, arguing that the plaintiff had assigned his copyright to Sony by agreeing to the contest’s rules. The district court adopted a magistrate judge’s recommendation granting summary judgment to the defendant, dismissed the plaintiff’s remaining claims, and invalidated the plaintiff’s copyright registration, all without permitting discovery.

On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit held that the district court abused its discretion by granting summary judgment and invalidating the copyright registration without affording the plaintiff a fair opportunity to conduct discovery, particularly since the relevant evidence was largely under the defendant’s and Sony’s control. The First Circuit vacated the district court’s summary judgment order and the invalidation of the copyright registration, remanding the case for further proceedings to allow discovery. View “Cortes-Ramos v. Martin-Morales” on Justia Law