Bitmanagement Software GmBH (“Bitmanagement”) developed software for rendering three-dimensional graphics, specifically “BS Contact Geo,” which was used by the United States Navy (“Navy”) in conjunction with its SPIDERS 3D platform. Initially, Bitmanagement provided the Navy with 100 seat licenses, allowing installation on 100 computers. In 2012, the Navy switched to a floating license, permitting installation on multiple computers but limiting simultaneous users to 20, monitored by a tracking application called Flexera. However, Flexera failed to limit usage, and the software was installed on over 429,000 Navy computers.

The United States Court of Federal Claims initially found no liability for copyright infringement. Bitmanagement appealed, and the Federal Circuit held that the Navy’s failure to use Flexera breached a material condition of the implied license, constituting copyright infringement. The case was remanded to the Court of Federal Claims to calculate damages. On remand, the court awarded Bitmanagement $154,400, based on a hypothetical negotiation for a combination of seat and floating licenses, rather than per-copy damages.

The United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit reviewed the case and affirmed the lower court’s decision. The Federal Circuit held that the Court of Federal Claims did not abuse its discretion in awarding damages based on the Navy’s actual usage of the software rather than the number of copies made. The court found that the hypothetical negotiation would have resulted in a primarily usage-based licensing scheme, supported by the parties’ past licensing practices and the evidence presented. The court also upheld the admission of the government’s damages expert’s testimony and found no error in the burden of proof allocation. View “BITMANAGEMENT SOFTWARE GMBH v. US ” on Justia Law